Difference between revisions of "Musical Comparison of Major Methods"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Added page) |
m (added Sheffield S) |
||
Line 52: | Line 52: | ||
|333||Turramurra Surprise||735||Virgo Surprise | |333||Turramurra Surprise||735||Virgo Surprise | ||
|- | |- | ||
− | |321||Lancashire Surprise|| | + | |321||Lancashire Surprise||726||Sheffield Surprise |
|- | |- | ||
− | |316||Pudsey Surprise|| | + | |316||Pudsey Surprise||718||Yorkshire Surprise |
|- | |- | ||
− | |314||Mareham Delight|| | + | |314||Mareham Delight||707||Turramurra Surprise |
|- | |- | ||
− | |312||Tennessine Surprise|| | + | |312||Tennessine Surprise||691||Cadmium Surprise |
|- | |- | ||
− | |306||Yorkshire Surprise||686||Yeading Surprise | + | |306||Yorkshire Surprise||689||Belfast Surprise |
+ | |- | ||
+ | |289||Sheffield Surprise||686||Yeading Surprise | ||
|- | |- | ||
|274||Rutland Surprise||682||Rutland Surprise | |274||Rutland Surprise||682||Rutland Surprise |
Latest revision as of 18:11, 2 November 2018
One of the objectives of the Project Pickled Egg project is to identify Treble Dodging Major methods that are musical in their plain course and can be rung to musical compositions. This page lists many of the methods discussed on the PPE Discussion Facebook Group together with some of the traditionally popular methods for comparison.
The methods have been ranked by descending music score based upon the highest scoring composition found in October 2018 using an extended search in Composition Library using its default music score. For a fair comparison the length has been limited to conventional length quarters (1250-1440 changes) and peals (5000-5280 changes).
Score | In quarter peals | Score | in peals |
---|---|---|---|
637 | Double Dublin Surprise | 1195 | Double Norwich Court Bob |
628 | Venusium Surprise | 1182 | Bristol Surprise |
594 | Deva Surprise | 1102 | Plain Bob |
564 | Double Norwich Court Bob | 1084 | Deva Surprise |
549 | Bristol Surprise | 1009 | Double Dublin Surprise |
520 | Bimini Surprise | 1001 | Cooktown Orchid |
486 | Jevington Surprise | 987 | Venusium Surprise |
464 | Plain Bob | 975 | Kenninghall Surprise |
413 | Deira Surprise | 927 | Cornwall Surprise |
396 | Cooktown Orchid | 911 | Lancashire Surprise |
391 | Muppet Show Surprise | 862 | Jevington Surprise |
384 | Kenninghall Surprise | 860 | Superlative Surprise |
383 | Cornwall Surprise | 850 | Deira Surprise |
380 | Yeading Surprise | 846 | Lessness Surprise |
365 | Belfast Surprise | 842 | Kent Treble Bob |
364 | Kent Treble Bob | 829 | Bimini Surprise |
362 | Coniston Bluebird Delight | 826 | Coniston Bluebird Delight |
360 | Superlative Surprise | 825 | Uxbridge Surprise |
360 | Virgo Surprise | 815 | Tennessine Surprise |
353 | Lessness Surprise | 799 | Watford Delight |
353 | Uxbridge Surprise | 760 | Mareham Delight |
348 | Watford Delight | 753 | Muppet Show Surprise |
333 | Turramurra Surprise | 735 | Virgo Surprise |
321 | Lancashire Surprise | 726 | Sheffield Surprise |
316 | Pudsey Surprise | 718 | Yorkshire Surprise |
314 | Mareham Delight | 707 | Turramurra Surprise |
312 | Tennessine Surprise | 691 | Cadmium Surprise |
306 | Yorkshire Surprise | 689 | Belfast Surprise |
289 | Sheffield Surprise | 686 | Yeading Surprise |
274 | Rutland Surprise | 682 | Rutland Surprise |
266 | London Surprise | 681 | Chenies Surprise |
255 | Cambridge Surprise | 680 | Cambridge Surprise |
243 | Chenies Surprise | 664 | London Surprise |
241 | Cadmium Surprise | 632 | Pudsey Surprise |
241 | Lincolnshire Surprise | 600 | Lincolnshire Surprise |
239 | Buckfastleigh Surprise | 587 | Glasgow Surprise |
227 | Glasgow Surprise | 519 | Buckfastleigh Surprise |