Music in Changeringing

What is Music in Changeringing?

Although non-ringers appreciate the overall effect created by bells rung to changes, and can hear differences between call changes and method ringing, or odd bell methods with a cover compared with even bell methods, further musical appreciation is something acquired through study, generally by ringers themselves as they become more experienced in listening to method ringing. So what do ringers mean when they refer to music?

Music in ringing is the appreciation of the musical properties of individual rows contained in a touch, and the sequence in which rows are heard. The sequence of rows is determined by the choice of method; consequently one will hear people say things like "Bristol [Surprise] is a musical method" or "that was a very musical touch of Stedman". The reason for this is that people like the way that a particular method generates repetitions and rotations of a subset of bells within the rows. Methods can be rung to compositions that maximise the musical combinations of bells within the rows without causing any repetition of entire rows which would render the touch false.

For example, the first lead of a plain course of Bristol Surprise Major contains many musical characteristics as described below:

 12345678  Rounds
 21436587  Combination near miss
 12346857  1234 cascade (little bell run), 6857 is a musical combination 
 21438675  
 24136857  pairs in musical thirds (2&4, 1&3, 6&8, 5&7)
 42316587
 24135678  5678 roll up
 42315768
 24351786
 23457168  2345 cascade
 32541786
 35247168
 53427618  pairs in musical thirds (5&3, 2&4)
 35246781
 32547618
 23456781  2345678 run (encompassing a 2345 cascade and an internal 5678 roll up)
 24365871  Wrap of a combination near miss (1-2436587)
 42638517
 46235871
 64328517
 46238157
 42631875  pairs in musical thirds (4&2, 5&7)
 24368157
 23461875
 32416857  6857 is a musical combination (consecutive thirds)
 23146587
 32415678  5678 roll up
 23145768
 21347586  7586  is a musical combination (reverse of 6857)
 12435768  Combination near miss
 21345678  5678 roll up
 12436587  Combination near miss
 14263857

In just these few rows, a number of musical features are apparent. The back bells and front bells are kept together in groups of four. The back four bells hunt for three rows causing 6&8 and 5&7 to work together (musical thirds). They then backward hunt back for three more rows giving the same four bell combinations in reverse order, until the back four are in the rounds position again (xxxx5678). This is called a roll up, and roll ups are often counted and quoted in composition as a favoured musical combinations to listen out for. The sequence in which roll ups and other musical combinations occur is important as some methods generate them in an interesting way and some in a tedious way. Westminster Surpise Major, for example, has the back four bells dodging seven times. This generates seven roll ups in fourteen rows, but is very repetitive. Returning to Bristol, the front four bells start by dodging back into their rounds position giving what is called a little bell run, or cascade. Runs of four or more consecutive bells, either forwards or backwards are another sequence that ringers enjoy listening to - many compositions and methods, especially cyclic ones, concentrate on maximising the number of runs. The front bells, like the back bells, also work together 2&4 and 1&3, then 2&4 and 3&5, creating musical thirds. At the half lead, a seven bell run (23456781) occurs at handstroke, and adjacent pairs of bells (3&4, 5&6 and 7&8) swap. This gives similar reversed musical combinations in the second half of the lead. The bells at the front and back again work in their respective four bell groups, and two more roll ups occur. If a fourths place bob is called at the lead end, the back four bells dodge back into their rounds position, and the whole lead of music of these four bells is repeated against different front bell combinations. This is known as the extending lead feature of methods with a first leadhead of 14263857 (group mx) and the three lead touch of Bristol produced by calling a bob at every leadend is perhaps a classic example of a short musical touch, as it contains a large number of musical combinations generated and repeated in an interesting way. Finally, Bristol is a double method, so all the music is reversed e.g. Back Rounds occurs half-way through the plain course.

Listen to 3 leads of Bristol Surprise Major

As we move up the stages (increasing numbers of bells), we ring only a subset of the available rows e.g. a quarter of the available rows in a quarterpeal of Triples. So on higher stages, the composition becomes important as well as the method, as the composer can select, within the constraints of method construction and falseness, courses of the method containing better musical combinations. This is not to say that there are not musical touches of Doubles and Minor, but the composer's choices are fairly limited. In an extent of a particular method, the only significant variable is whether the rows occur at handstroke or backstroke.

At odd stages, methods are commonly rung with the tenor covering. This creates very distinctive music resulting from the constant beat set by the tenor ringing last in every row. Compositions in methods such as Grandsire and Stedman typically focus on turning sets of bells into a musical sequence (e.g. Tittums, Reverse Tittums, Queens, Whittingtons, Handstroke or Backstroke Homes) and then repeating that sequence for a number of courses before turning them into another musical combination.

Listen to Stedman Caters in the Tittums position

The remainder of this article covers individual musical features, their nomenclature, definition and examples of how they are used.

Roll-ups

A row where the back bells are in the rounds position e.g. xxxx567890 on ten bells. Note that xxxxxx7890 would also be referred to as a roll-up, as would xxxxxxx90, so the term is often qualified e.g. 5-6, 7-8 or 9-10 roll-up. The term roll-up is often assumed under compositions e.g. 20 56s & 20 65s means 20 5-6 roll ups and 20 6-5 roll-ups.

Combination roll-ups (crus)

The number of combinations of 4,5 & 6 in 5-6 with heavier bells rolling up i.e. the rows xxxx5678, xxxx6578, xxxx4578, xxxx5478, xxxx4678 and xxxx6478, with a maximum of 144 possible. crus have limited value on more than eight bells, but counts are commonly given after compositions of Major and Royal.

Runs / little bell runs

A run is any four or more bells in rounds sequence, forwards or backwards. It can be at the beginning, the middle, or the end of a row (the norm unless otherwise stated). Since there is not a formal definition for counting purposes, compositions typically list them specifically (e.g. 16 23456s and 36 5432s). Some composers count using terms such as LB4s and LB5s referring to four and five little bell runs, however the lack of formal definition of a little bell means that it is unclear what counts as a LB4 or LB5 (some including up to the 7th to include runs such as 76543 and 34567).

Other four bell combinations

Other musical four bell combinations on eight bells, with their stems are:

 xxxx1357 (from Queens)
 xxxx2468 (from Queens)
 xxxx3468 (from Whittingtons)
 xxxx3478 (from Hagdyke)
 xxxx3578
 xxxx3748 (from Tittums)
 xxxx5768 (from Bowbells)
 xxxx6857 (from Bristol) 
 xxxx7468 (from Princesses)
 xxxx7568 (from Burdette)
 xxxx7658 (from Rollercoaster)
 xxxx8765 Esso-Blues (from the 1950's commercial)

Music off the front

Musical combinations measured at the front of the row rather than the back e.g. the row 56782143 has a 5678 roll up off the front.

At handstroke or backstroke

As most changeringing is rung with a handstroke gap, musical combinations sound different depending whether they are at handstroke or backstroke. At backstroke, a combination at the end of the row is more clearly defined than at handstroke,as it is followed by a pause. Conversely, a combination at the front is more clearly defined at handstroke. Some compositions state whether the combinations of runs occur at back or hand.

Cascades

A measure for little bell music, particularly useful on higher numbers i.e. the rows ending in ...1234, ...2345, ...3456, ...4321, ...5432, and ...6543. Like crus, there is maximum of 144 on eight bells, but on higher stages the maximum is also higher. They can also be counted off the front i.e. 1234..., 2345..., 3456... etc.

The Waterfall course

The course with the coursing order 24653, that generates rows ending ...23456 at backstroke in most even bell methods with Plain Bob coursing. The coursehead is 164523... Particularly popular on higher numbers, musically it is most satisfying on ten bells as the front six bells form their own major key group with the sixth as the tenor.

Near misses

A near miss is defined as any row that differs from rounds merely by having one adjacent pair of bells exchanged. On N bells there are always N-1 near misses possible.

So, for example, for caters, the eight possible near misses are

 213456789, 132456789, 124356789, 123546789,
 123465789, 123457689, 123456879, 123456798

If more than one pair of adjacent bells is swapped, it has been proposed that this be called a combination near miss.

Named rows

A few musical rows have been given names e.g. Rounds, Backrounds, Tittums, Queens, Whittingtons, Kings and Hagdyke. See row for definitions. Compositions often state when they contain named rows e.g. contains 144 crus, Queens, Whittingtons and Tittums.

Tittums / Handstroke Homes

In odd bell ringing, Tittums is used not just to refer to the named row, but also the Tittums position. This is the position where the back bells course down in rounds sequence to create a slow rounds effect e.g. xxxx5x6x7x8x9x0xExT with the gap to the tenor behind gradually increasing.

Another popular odd-bell position is the Handstroke Home, giving a very pleasing effect as back bells come back into the rounds position at handstroke. A large number of compositions of Grandsire and Stedman finish in this position, hence the odd number of changes.

Wraps

A Wrap is a musical row that is split over a handstroke and a backstroke. For example, every method with Plain Bob leadheads contains the following wrap of reverse rounds:

 18765432 handstroke
 18674523 backstroke

Another good one is the Whittingtons near-miss in the first lead of Double Norwich CBM. Listen out for it next time you ring the method - it sounds lovely:

 64821753 handstroke
 46812735 backstroke

Wraps are only effective if they cross a handstroke-backstroke change, because otherwise the handstroke gap interrupts them. It can be confusing for those listening outside a tower when a wrap of rounds occurs, as they may think that a touch has come round in the middle.

It is difficult to get many wraps in conventional methods, so some methods have been specially designed to maximize the number of wraps in the plain course. The principle Rapid Wrap Major (PN 36.1.56.3x345x34x56x78 23456781), designed by Mark B Davies, has 9 Wraps of Rounds in the plain course and a large number of Wraps of near misses.

 12345678  23456781  34567812  45678123  56781234  67812345  78123456  81234567
 21354687  32465718  43576821  54687132  65718243  76821354  87132465  18243576
 23145867  34256178  45367281  56478312  67581423  78612534  81723645  12834756
 32415876  43526187  54637218  65748321  76851432  87162543  18273654  21384765
 23451786  34562817  45673128  56784231  67815342  78126453  81237564  12348675
 32547168  43658271  54761382  65872413  76183524  87214635  18325746  21436857
 23547618  34658721  45761832  56872143  67183254  78214365  81325476  12436587
 32456781  43567812  54678123  65781234  76812345  87123456  18234567  21345678
 23457618  34568721  45671832  56782143  67813254  78124365  81235476  12346587
 32546781  43657812  54768123  65871234  76182345  87213456  18324567  21435678
 23456718  34567821  45678132  56781243  67812354  78123465  81234576  12345687
 32547681  43658712  54761823  65872134  76183245  87214356  18325467  21436578
 23456781  34567812  45678123  56781234  67812345  78123456  81234567  12345678

Listen to a plain course of Rapid Wrap Major

Undesirable music

As well as including leads of methods in compositions with musical rows, composers can avoid including undesirable rows. What is undesirable is often hotly debated, and there is less consensus than on what constitutes a musical row. The most common example is that many ringers like to avoid having the tenors reversed at backstroke (e.g. xxxxxx87s at backstroke). However, there are methods that have the tenors reversed at backstroke in their plain course (e.g. March Surprise Major).

Many compositions of Bristol Surprise Major produced in and around the 1970's used to quote no 82s and no 83s. These were considered untuneful because if struck together they would be a discordant 7th or 6th intervals. However, many of these compositions would be considered inferior today because the practice of avoiding 82s and 83s also eliminated some of the best little bell music e.g. the waterfall course, with its xxx23456s as well as xxxxxx83s.

See also

• Named rows

External links

• Bellringing and music Articles on ringing written for musicians